Skip to main content
Excellent5.0|394 reviews
  • Proudly family-owned, serving our community with care

December 13, 2024

8 Common Water Heater Problems & Troubleshooting Tips


Author of Article

Chad Stanek

Gray tank water heater next to blue tool box on floor in a basement.

You shower, wash dishes, run your washing machine, and do other water-related tasks throughout the day, never thinking about your water heater — until it malfunctions.

If you’re left looking for answers, don’t panic. Here, Comfort Zone Service dives into the six most common water heater issues and provides solutions to address them effectively.

Common Water Heater Issues & Tips To Fix Them

While DIY solutions are generally not suggested, you can try these tips to troubleshoot common water heater issues:

Lack of Hot Water

This problem can be caused by a faulty thermostat or broken heating element. If you have a gas heater, it can be caused by the pilot light.

To troubleshoot this problem, you’ll want to check your power supply to ensure your water heater is receiving power and inspect the thermostat to verify it’s properly set. For electric water heaters, you’ll want to examine your heating element using a multimeter.

Strange Noises

Rumbling and banging noises are often caused by sediment buildup in the tank. To troubleshoot this issue, you flush your tank to remove the sediment buildup and check for loose parts.

Water Leaks

Leaks can develop as a result of corrosion, cracks, or loose connections. To troubleshoot this, inspect your tank for leaks via visual inspection of the appliance and surrounding pipes or connections. Then, check the temperature and pressure relief valves and drain valves to ensure your tank isn’t experiencing excess pressure and that the drain valve is fully closed.

Temperature Fluctuations

Issues with thermostats or heating elements can result in inconsistent temperatures. To troubleshoot, inspect your thermostat to ensure it’s correctly set and functioning, then check your heating element.

Discolored Water

Discolored water can indicate corrosion within the tank or issues with the sacrificial anode rod. To troubleshoot, check the anode rod. If it’s worn out, the tank may begin to corrode or leak, and the rod will need to be replaced.

Low Water Pressure

This can be caused by sediment buildup or plumbing issues. To troubleshoot, flush the tank and inspect your plumbing.

Foul-Smelling Water

A rotten egg smell can be caused by bacterial growth inside the tank. To troubleshoot this, flush the tank and consider installing a water softener or filtration system.

Limescale Buildup in the Tank

Hard water causes limescale buildup. To troubleshoot this issue, treat your water before it reaches the tank with a water softener or water heater filter. Then, clean the tank to eliminate the existing limescale.

When To Call a Professional

If you’ve tried to resolve your water heater problems through these simple solutions and you’re still having issues, it’s time to call a professional. Delayed repairs can lead to further damage or complete system replacement.

Hiring a professional guarantees you’ll get solutions that root out and address the repairs at the source, ensuring uninterrupted and reliable hot water for your home.

Schedule Water Heater Services With Comfort Zone

 At Comfort Zone Service, we’re committed to delivering exceptional water heater repairs for your home. Our NATE-certified, background-checked, and drug-tested technicians provide same-say solutions to get your hot water flowing again in no time.

Whether you’re dealing with a minor leak, a malfunctioning thermostat, or a complete system breakdown, our team has the skills and experience to diagnose and resolve the issue efficiently.

Turn to Comfort Zone Service for prompt, reliable, and affordable service every time. 

Call us today to schedule water heater repairs in the Orland Park or Mokena area.

Free Estimate

Don’t take our word for it

See what folks around Chicago are saying

GoogleExcellent5.0|394 reviewsWrite a review
  • Terreyl MSep 2026

    Great experience with Comfort Zone Service from start to finish. Josh Berg came out to diagnose our thermostat issue, was punctual, professional, and took the time to thoroughly explain everything he found. Timothy Keenan and David Diaz handled our water heater replacement and did an excellent job removing the old unit and installing the new one. They arrived on time, worked efficiently, and cleaned everything up when they were finished. Very professional crew all around, and I would definitely recommend Comfort Zone Service!

  • Michael DAug 2026

    Our hot water heater stopped working. I called Comfort Zone because they were close and had good reviews. Jordan was at my house a few hours later to troubleshoot the problem. Turns out we needed a new unit. He was back out at my house the following morning by 9a starting the installation. Before lunchtime they were finished and we had hot water again! I would recommend Comfort Zone to anyone needing help with HVAC or hot water heaters. Thanks so much!

  • Mike DJan 2026

    Tim Keenan and David Diaz installed a new furnace, hot water heater, and whole house humidifier. I could not be happier with the installation, they answered all the questions I had, cleaned up after themselves, and hauled the old units away. The price from Comfort Zone was great and much cheaper than anticipated. Would definitely recommend to anyone looking for any type of HVAC service.

  • Lynn MDec 2024

    Thank you Chad for your fast response to fix my water heater! Fast, reliable, and knowledgeable. Love supporting local businesses and can always depend on Comfort Zone. Highly recommend!

  • Sharon RJul 2021

    As always, Comfort Zone came to the rescue when my hot water heater went out. Great company. Great, knowledgeable techs.

  • Ryan HJan 2021

    Very quick response time! I noticed the failure of my hot water heater at 7pm one evening, and had a new hot water heater installed and ready to go by 11am the next morning. Great communication, clear recommendations, and took the time to explain details about the equipment that was ultimately installed.

  • Lynn MApr 2018

    What an amazing family owned company!! Quick response to service requests, fair and honest! Very responsive, knowledgeable and reliable. Very satisfied repeat customer here. Can not recommend anyone better for your HVAC and additional hot water tank issues.

  • Thomas LMar 2017

    I had a new hot water installed from another contractor. almost immediately I had issues and they would not even come out to look at it. I called Comfort Zone and they came out the same day. They diagnosed the problem as being the controls of the a. o. smith water heater. they ordered the new part and came out to install right away. I was very happy with the way they responded to my needs. I would definitely call them again for any future work I needed to have done.

Book Online